Janet Siclari’s Surfside Homicide

Update on Thomas Berry ā€” Rapist and Killer
(“A Cinderella Story,” Forensic Files)

If you’re looking for a defendant who’s undeserving of sympathy and makes you thankful the U.S. has life sentences without parole, Thomas Jabin Berry is just the ticket.

Janet Siclari
Janet Siclari

As Forensic Files watchers will remember, Berry’s excuse for sexually assaulting a 12-year-old girl was that he thought she was 13.

Fortunately, that victim survived the attack. But Berry killed the next person he raped, an ultrasound technician from New Jersey named Janet Siclari.

Her story. For this week, I checked on Berry’s whereabouts today and also looked for additional biographical information on Janet Siclari.

So, let’s get started on a recap of Forensic Files episode “A Cinderella Story,” along with extra information drawn from internet research.

Janet Siclari came into the world on Dec. 30, 1957, and grew up in Lyndhurst, New Jersey, with three brothers.

Favorite getaway. She earned a certificate in radiology in 1979 and got the highest academic awards in her class. Janet moved to North Arlington and worked at General Hospital in Passaic.

Photo of the book Forensic Files Now
BOOK IN STORES AND ONLINE!

For Janet, visiting North Carolina’s Outer Banks in the summer was a family tradition that started in her childhood.

In August 1993, the 35-year-old vacationed there with her brother Robert Siclari and two friends, Celeste Bethmann and Nancy Matt. They stayed at a rental cottage in Southern Shores for a week, then decided to spend an extra day in the area and checked into the Carolinian hotel in Nags Head.

Eerie feeling. Siclari, who was athletic but tiny at 92 pounds, disappeared after a night out at a comedy club followed by drinks and dancing at the Port O’Call Restaurant & Gaslight Saloon on Aug. 28. Robert was asleep when she came home but remembered waking up briefly and hearing her say she was going outside to smoke.

Janet Siclari with her brother Robert Siclari and two girlfriends at the beach
Janet Siclari, left, with her brother Robert and two friends

In the morning, Robert noticed his sister’s bed hadn’t been slept in and saw police on the beach outside his window, according to an account from the Bergen Record.

A local maintenance crew worker had found her body, dressed in a blue tank top, outside the hotel. Someone had stabbed her repeatedly, slit her throat, and left her to die.

Stormy circumstances. “Blood seeped in the white sand 25 feet in either direction,” according to a Bergen Record account from Feb. 2, 1999. Apparently, Janet had survived for a short time after the attack and tried to crawl back to the hotel.

The day after the murder, Hurricane Emily caused tens of thousands to flee the area temporarily, but police didn’t let it get in the way of their work.

A tantalizing suspect soon emerged in a burly bartender, Edward Read Powell, who had flirted with Janet and later admitted to police that he was sitting around eating pepperoni with a knife near the scene of the murder.

Book cover
BOOK IN STORES AND ONLINE!

Hostile waitress. Although Forensic Files didn’t mention it, three additional prospective perpetrators came to light as well, according to “Murder in Paradise,” a 2013 episode of Nightmare Next Door.

There was Powell’s waitress girlfriend, who exchanged surly words with Janet’s brother when he sent his food back at her restaurant ā€” and she’d seen Read socializing with Janet.

The third suspect, a cabana attendant who hit on Janet and reportedly made her a little uncomfortable, was also questioned by police, who discovered he had a past conviction for stabbing a relative.

Bring in the feds. Next, thanks to a tip from Janet’s mother, investigators checked out Janet’s ex-boyfriend, a New Jersey mechanic and biker club member. He had served time in prison as an accessory to the murder of a man from a rival gang.

Rapist and killer Thomas Jabin Berry
Thomas Berry in court

But one by one, the four suspects fell away.

An autopsy revealed that Janet had been raped, so investigators ruled out the waitress as the killer. And none of the DNA samples collected from the male suspects matched the rapist’s genetic profile.

The FBI came in to help local authorities, but a year after the murder, they hadn’t found a single eyewitness despite interviewing 100 people in connection with the case, according to the Bergen Record. The area had a low stranger-on-stranger crime rate, so there weren’t a lot of usual-suspect types to haul in for questioning.

Funds offered. Robert Siclari, who owned an environmental consulting firm in Alexandria, Virginia, put together a $20,000 reward for information that would help solve the crime.

“We lost Janet and we can’t bring her back,” Robert told the Virginian-Pilot. “But we don’t want something like this to happen to someone else.”

Still, the case turned cold.

Then, in 1997, something wonderful happened in the world of forensic science. CODIS ā€” the combined DNA indexing system ā€” was created so police across the U.S. could share genetic profiles of convicted felons.

Knife wielder. When authorities entered Janet Siclari’s rape kit sample in the database, they got a match with Thomas Jabin Berry. The roofer and commercial fisherman, who was 27 at the time of the murder, had undergone DNA testing after committing a parole violation.

The Carolinian, seen here in a vintage post card, fell into disrepair and closed, but East Carolina University maintains a webpage where former guests can share old memories of the Nag’s Head property.

Berry’s ex-girlfriend told police that he always carried a fishing knife and that a pair of shoes and socks found near Janet Siclari’s body belonged to him.

The findings about Berry, who lived in the North Carolina towns of Engelhard and Manteo, weren’t exactly a shock. His record included “indecent liberty with a child” involving the aforementioned 12-year-old girl.

Talk about a lowlife. During his on-camera interview with Forensic Files, Berry ā€” who had three children by two different women ā€” called his actions toward the girl “consensual.”

Apparently no one had informed him that children can’t consent.

The girl would later testify that Berry had lured her into the woods under the guise of helping him find a lost nephew. Then he raped her in a fort, according to court papers from North Carolina vs. Berry in 2001.

Crack defense. Berry got a 10-year suspended sentence for his crime against the 12-year-old girl.

Under police questioning for the attack on Janet Siclari, Berry said he had been smoking crack cocaine at the time and couldn’t remember whether he had raped and killed Janet, according to the court papers.

Book cover
BOOK IN STORES AND ONLINE!

In his Forensic Files interview, Berry said that, if he did have sex with Janet, “it would have been consensual” and he never killed anybody. He also said he sometimes had sex with people he just met on the beach and that was how he met his wife.

Third victim. Doris Berry, the suspect’s mother, strenuously defended him, saying he was “not capable of committing murder” even “to save his own life.” Meanwhile, her son had a history of sex crimes dating back to when he himself was 12 years old, according to a Bergen Record account.

At the trial, a woman named Shelley Perry testified that Berry had tried to rape her after breaking into her house in 1992. She managed to escape and never pressed charges.

In 1999, a jury convicted Thomas Berry of the rape and first-degree murder of Janet Siclari.

Sympathy for the devil. At the sentencing hearing, Janet Siclari’s mother, Damy Siclari Daber, spoke of how the death had devastated the family and said that son Robert Siclari felt guilty. “I tell him it’s not his fault … It’s that maniac’s fault,” she said, as reported by the Virginian-Pilot on Jan. 28, 1999.

Thomas Berry in a recent mug shot

Meanwhile, Doris Berry portrayed her son as a victim ā€” a sweet guy who was severely abused by his father and used to hide in the woods to escape him, the Virginian-Pilot reported.

The defense also attempted to win the jury members’ sympathy by showing them a childhood photo of Thomas Berry holding a fish he had caught.

Good prisoner. But in the end, the jury didn’t think his case held water.

Berry received two consecutive life sentences.

Today, Thomas Berry resides in Warren Correctional Institution in Manson, North Carolina. He lost a 2001 appeal and is not eligible for parole.

Berry is housed in medium security. Born on Jan. 4, 1966, he has a lot of years ahead of him, and all of them are highly likely to be spent behind razor wire.

That’s all for this post. Until next week, cheers. ā€” RR


Watch the Forensic Files episode on YouTube

Book cover
Book online and in stores!

32 thoughts on “Janet Siclari’s Surfside Homicide”

  1. Iā€™d need to rewatch the episode to see its direction, but I also wonder why itā€™s called A Cinderella Story? Perhaps it is simply an error out of so many episodes.

    1. I thought it was a mix-up in names as well, too — until readers mentioned the abandoned sneakers that fit the murderer.

      1. That makes the most sense. It’s messed up if they were implying she was the Cinderella. He was no prince charming for her. It saddened me for her, she’s around my age and just wanted to find her prince. Can’t even take a quick cigarette break with out a lying, raping, murdering piece of human trash ending your life. Ugh. I’m glad they nailed his ass.

    2. Because she broke up with her boyfriend of ten years in order to find that perfect prince charming…and so the irony is she found the devil.

    3. Because she was 35 and looking for the perfect guy. The episode indicated she would have never run off with a stranger like that.

  2. He sometimes had sex with women he just met on the beach and that was how he met his wife.

    OMG.

    Great recap.

  3. Thanks, Rebecca. Don’t think I’ve seen this one. It’s tenuous, but could Cindarella (aka The Little Glass Slipper) refer to Berry’s shoes that matched the prints at the beach by the body, being material in catching him? Thus ‘a bad story’ turned out ‘better’ (if not well) ‘cos of ‘shoes’? As said – tenuous!

    He’s total trash. We understand a mother’s love – but unless she was unaware of his gross conviction history for harming others she was surely deluded in suggesting he’s safe on the streets… Some perps, either through the gravity or quantum of their dangerous crimes, are too unsafe ever to be free. He’s one – period.

    1. What about the part where he tells the jailer about one of the jurors knowing him and that same juror was the only one to vote against death penalty ā€” how was the juror not removed ? Or does it work differently in the US?

  4. Reason for the title:
    From IMDb (Internet Movie Database) ā€œPolice were sure that if they found the man who fit the shoes, they would also find the man who committed the crime.ā€œ

  5. Great recap! I love reading these “Where are they now” blogs/articles. I can’t wait to read the next one. Thank you again for updating us, Rebecca. You do an awesome job!

  6. What a psychopath. I never understood what forensic psychiatrists meant by ā€œsuperficial charmā€ until I watched this guy talking about all the ā€œconsensualā€ sex he had. He reminds me of a certain narcissistic president who also thinks heā€™s never done anything wrong.

    1. Lilikoian, I hate politics but I have to agree. People who commit sexual assaults are not just after sex. It’s the power they crave. They have a sense of entitlement. Their actions are always right. I grab them by the genitals, I do what I want. I had consensual sex with that 12 year old. She wanted it. They all did, right?

      This man is where he belongs. I prefer to think instead about Janet’s path to employment and where she might be today had she lived.

  7. Just watched this episode. Your recap is excellent. I wasnā€™t sure why they gave it that title either but the comments helped to clarify that itā€™s probably because he left his shoes. This predator is exactly where he should be for life!

    1. Thanks — so glad you enjoyed the recap.

      Yep, no chance of rehabilitating Thomas Berry. He needs to stay behind razor wire.

  8. RR- The title “Cinderella Story”: Think about the children’s story- Cinderella goes to the ball has a fairy tale, wonderful, enchanting evening but at midnight all the wonder disappears as time of magic runs out and reality crashes down. Kind of what happens to poor Ms. Siclari. My take anyhow!

  9. My favourite part of this episode is when her friend say ā€œJanet wasnā€™t done partying so we left her the car because we felt that was safer for her to drive and is to walkā€ ā€œkeep partying Jan donā€™t wrap your car around a tree on your way to getting raped and murderedā€

    1. Well that was my favourite part till the killer said ā€œthat girl wasnā€™t 12 ā€” she was 14. I have the paperwork to prove it or at least she was 13 going on twelve.ā€

  10. How could they put in an interview with a friend saying this just didn’t happen to people who led “good and decent” lives…was the 12 year old girl not good and decent? Does anyone who she didn’t feel to lead “good and decent” lives deserve to be raped and murdered?

    1. Such remarks illustrate why the views, as value judgements, of family and friends – as opposed to their relevant factual testimony – are irrelevant because of their subjectivity. Hence his mother’s absurd claims. Who cares what she thinks? She’s family; blood’s thicker than water.

      Per current issue, it’s like asking Ms E DeGeneres’s ‘wife’ whether claims that ED’s a nasty bully are true, or expecting that the latter might express anything other than refutation. Yet such trivial rubbish is still reported…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: